Finished off with nice full cloth binding, it's a nice production, with a heft as substantial as the information contained inside. Gottfried's study pairs a page-sized map on the right side, with a full page of explanatory text on the left. As a system it works well. My only significant complaint is with the lack of a clearly declared time element attached to each map. Uncertainty of the timing of chaotic historical events is a given, but the inclusion of an estimated range based on the best available source information would have been very helpful. This beef aside, Gottfried's study is a very impressive map collection. One can only hope that this is the beginning of a series...in fact, rumblings of a Chickamauga project from highly regarded expert Dave Powell have been heard.
*** Note also that, in a move boardgame veterans can appreciate, Savas Beatie has made available for download some errata pages. To find them, just scroll down to the Updated Pages box. ***
As a map fan, I will find this interesting, but today I think maps must be available in digital form compatible with GIS software or are obsolete.
ReplyDelete"...minor Pennsylvania pillow fight" I LOVE IT! I had a friend who used to refer to Gettysburg as "the Westport of the East."
ReplyDeleteScott,
ReplyDeleteWhile I don't agree with you on the issue of obsolescence, it would be a helpful and interesting option to offer; especially for battlefields more difficult to visualize today than Gettysburg.
Thanks for writing,
Drew
Albert,
ReplyDeletePerhaps we'll see a Price Raid map study some day. We can dream.
Drew