Friday, May 3, 2019

Booknotes: Life In Jefferson Davis' Navy

New Arrival:
• Life In Jefferson Davis' Navy by Barbara Brooks Tomblin (Naval Inst Press, 2019).

On several occasions I've mentioned how much I like Tomblin's work, and I've reviewed her prior Civil War titles Bluejackets and Contrabands: African Americans and the Union Navy (2009) and The Civil War on the Mississippi: Union Sailors, Gunboat Captains, and the Campaign to Control the River (2016) here on the site. I still think the latter is the best overview of the topic. The author switches sides and publisher with her new book Life In Jefferson Davis' Navy.

From the description: "The Civil War is often considered a "soldiers' war," but Life in Jefferson Davis' Navy acknowledges the legacy of service of the officers and sailors of the Confederate States Navy. In this full-length study, Barbara Brooks Tomblin addresses every aspect of a Confederate seaman's life, from the risks of combat to the everyday routines which sustained those sailing for the stars and bars. Drawing upon diaries, letters, newspaper accounts, and published works, Tomblin offers a fresh look at the wartime experiences of the officers and men in the Confederate Navy, including those who served on gunboats, ironclads, and ships on western rivers and along the coast and at Mobile Bay, as well as those who sailed on the high seas aboard the Confederate raiders Sumter, Alabama, Florida, and Shenandoah."

The study adopts a pretty comprehensive perspective on what it was like to be a Confederate sailor. Chapters cover recruitment, shipboard induction, duties and routine, how sailors spent their free time, naval discipline, healthcare, and the POW experience. A pair of chapters summarize Confederate coastal and riverine naval operations, and another explores experimental and innovative technologies employed by the CSN.

Thursday, May 2, 2019

Booknotes: An East Texas Family’s Civil War

New Arrival:
• An East Texas Family’s Civil War: The Letters of Nancy and William Whatley, May–December 1862 edited by John T. Whatley (LSU Press, 2019).

An East Texas Family’s Civil War: The Letters of Nancy and William Whatley, May–December 1862 looks like an interesting, if rather brief, correspondence collection. From the description: Over the second half of 1862, "William Jefferson Whatley and his wife, Nancy Falkaday Watkins Whatley, exchanged a series of letters that vividly demonstrate the quickly changing roles of women whose husbands left home to fight in the Civil War. When William Whatley enlisted with the Confederate Army in 1862, he left his young wife Nancy in charge of their cotton farm in East Texas, near the village of Caledonia in Rusk County. 

In letters to her husband, Nancy describes in elaborate detail how she dealt with and felt about her new role, which thrust her into an array of unfamiliar duties, including dealing with increasingly unruly slaves, overseeing the harvest of the cotton crop, and negotiating business transactions with unscrupulous neighbors. At the same time, she carried on her traditional family duties and tended to their four young children during frequent epidemics of measles and diphtheria. Stationed hundreds of miles away, her husband could only offer her advice, sympathy, and shared frustration."

William enlisted in the Seventeenth Texas Cavalry, which was organized in the spring of 1862 and sent to Arkansas to bolster that state's defenses when they were denuded after Pea Ridge to reinforce Confederate forces across the Mississippi at Corinth. Spoiler alert ... I was curious as to why the letters ended in December 1862, assuming that William was killed or captured at Arkansas Post. In actuality, it was Nancy who sadly died nursing her children during a home front measles outbreak. William survived the war only to pass away in 1866.

More from the description: In An East Texas Family’s Civil War, "the Whatleys’ great-grandson, John T. Whatley, transcribes and annotates these letters for the first time. Notable for their descriptions of the unraveling of the local slave labor system and accounts of rural southern life, Nancy’s letters offer a rare window on the hardships faced by women on the home front taking on unprecedented responsibilities and filling unfamiliar roles."

Wednesday, May 1, 2019

Review - "A Bloody Day at Gaines' Mill: The Battlefield Debut of the Army of Northern Virginia, June 27, 1862" by Elmer Woodard

[A Bloody Day at Gaines' Mill: The Battlefield Debut of the Army of Northern Virginia, June 27, 1862 by Elmer R. Woodard, III (McFarland, 2019). Softcover, 19 maps, photos, illustrations, orders of battle, notes, bibliography, index. Pages main/total:vii,229/293. ISBN:978-1-4766-7357-8. $39.95]

It's no great secret that the military historiography of the 1862 Peninsula Campaign and its Seven Days series of battles remains strikingly underdeveloped. Available campaign overviews, among them works from Stephen Sears, David Martin, Joseph Cullen, and most recently Rudolph Schroeder, all leave significant room for improvement. Overall dissatisfaction with depth and scale reaches similar levels with the existing Seven Days studies from Clifford Dowdey, Judkin Browning, and Douglas Crenshaw. Only Brian Burton's Extraordinary Circumstances: The Seven Days Battles (2001) satisfies on most levels. When it comes to standalone battle studies, there are few titles worthy of mention and most Peninsula Campaign battles, large and small, still have no books devoted to them at all. With existing coverage limited to articles and chapter collections contained within more general works like those mentioned above, Elmer Woodard's A Bloody Day at Gaines' Mill: The Battlefield Debut of the Army of Northern Virginia, June 27, 1862 represents the most ambitious attempt to date at creating a truly comprehensive micro-scale history of the signature battle and dramatic turning point of the Seven Days. While the effort is laudable and most welcome, the results are a bit mixed.

Beginning his study in June 1862, Woodard gets right to the action, largely dispensing with the established traditions of introducing officers, major or minor, with short biographies and providing extensive background coverage of events and strategies leading up to the battle. The author does at length map out the road network north and west of Gaines' Mill, detailing along the way the converging approach marches of Stonewall Jackson's Valley Army and each element of Robert E. Lee's attack wing of his heavily reinforced Army of Northern Virginia.

In setting up the following day's epic clash, the text offers constructive overviews of the June 26 Battle of Beaver Dam Creek and the staged Union withdrawal to the high ground overlooking Boatswain's Creek in front and the Chickahominy bridges to the rear. The book's description of the midday picket battle that developed along Powhite Creek is well done and properly credits the action there for contributing to the main battle's onset being delayed until mid-afternoon. General Lee's original assumption of the enemy's main line of defense being behind Powhite Creek caused him to develop an initial attack plan that misread enemy intentions. By the time the true location of Union general Fitz John Porter's ably situated Fifth Corps was fully appreciated by Lee the only option available to get at the enemy before nightfall was a costly frontal attack.

The author's portrayal of Jackson as very active at the front and in constant communication with Lee offers a counterpoint to those that believe Jackson to have been uncharacteristically indolent and perhaps already showing early signs of the mental and physical exhaustion that many believe to have finally overwhelmed the general at White Oak Swamp. A better explanation for his "lateness" to Gaines' Mill might be a combination of factors classic to the 'friction of war' (ex. guide misunderstandings leading to route errors, staff incompetence, and typical problems coordinating widely dispersed columns). At least some confusion and delay will arise when an enemy army presents itself in completely unanticipated fashion. Technically, the author is correct that Jackson was not "late" given that men under his command were present with and directly supported A.P. Hill's initial assault, but Arnold Elzey's Brigade was just the vanguard of Richard Ewell's Division and the bulk of the Valley Army was still stacked up to the rear when Hill's Light Division was repulsed with heavy loss.

Though perhaps exaggerated in its degree of import, Woodard's historiographical complaint over previous Seven Days writers carelessly using 1864 maps of the Gaines's Mill/Cold Harbor area to describe 1862 events represents a valid concern. In the book, Woodard and cartographer Hal Jesperson construct a detailed topographical map (see pg. 61) of the battlefield that the author feels best fits the historical record. Offered in the text are a series of rather vivid descriptions of the geographical extent and militarily-relevant physical properties of those terrain features that figured most prominently in the battle. Several are given nicknames (ex. "Zouave Hill" and "Griffin's Woods") that remind readers of their close association with particular fighting units.

The Gaines' Mill battle concentrated large numbers of combatants on a very narrow front with terrain that frequently fragmented attacking formations. Adding to the modern chronicler's difficulties in sorting out the sequence of events are the inherent inexactitude of mid-nineteenth century time stamping and the fact that the battle consisted of a series of heavy attacks carried out over a short period of time between roughly 3-4 p.m. and nightfall. Nevertheless, the author is keen to wade in with his own version of how the battle played out. Though understandably focusing somewhat more on the attacking Confederates, the battle narrative exhibits a good faith effort on the part of the author at presenting both sides of the action. Generally speaking, attention to small-unit detail is evenly spread among both armies, and Porter's defensive arrangements are very clearly and comprehensively laid out for the reader in both maps and text.

When reading Woodard's uniquely detailed account of the fighting at Gaines' Mill, one is immediately struck by the size of the gaps that exist in earlier accounts (including Burton's). Whatever the accuracy of the interpretation in places, the battle narrative fills in those gaps with a reasonably coherent narrative of events that plausibly recalls the timing, sequence, and extent of the series of Confederate attacks that eventually overwhelmed the Union defenses. In the main, Woodard is more concerned with providing his own version of events than pointing out interpretive differences with other authors, though there is certainly some of that. Rather than focusing once again on the famous breakthrough moment of Chase Whiting's Division, the author elects instead to emphasize how the joint efforts of Whiting's Division, Archer's Brigade, three brigades (Pickett's, Pryor's, and Wilcox's) from Longstreet's Division, and some independent-acting regiments together created an irreparable breach in the Union line during a half-hour period between roughly 6:30 p.m. and 7.

Some readers will view with disfavor the author's decision to fragment his chapter narratives by breaking up the text into numerous action subsections (most often by military unit or formation), though their arrangement is sensible enough. While non-traditional in form, the content of Woodard's account of the battle is conventional in the sense that its backbone is formed by the O.R. and the text is richly supplemented with quoted passages from firsthand accounts written by participants of all ranks. Though it's difficult to get an overall sense of the breadth of research when the source list is not subdivided by category, the bibliography seems substantial enough (with some notable deficiencies, in newspapers for example) and might fairly be described as adequate but not exhaustive.

With some elements of the study, accepted practices are more radically altered. In an attempt to facilitate a more organized means of tracking temporary, ad-hoc collections of regiments formed from fragmented brigades, the author created for narrative purposes his own artificial brigade-equivalents (calling them "battle groups"). Many readers might find this well-intentioned innovation helpful, but one suspects that those more fully accustomed to sorting out complex battle lines will find the addition of another org layer (especially a non-historical one) an unnecessarily heavy-handed intervention. Undoubtedly, reactions will vary. Though harmless, other aspects of Woodard's writing are more oddly idiosyncratic. Examples include the author's ahistorical designation of Lee's offensive as "Operation Chickahominy," and his labeling of Union and Confederate brigadier generals as 'Brigadier X' in the modern British fashion. He also frequently applies his own colorful nicknames to the military geography (ex. coining the stretch of Union defensive line where the decisive breakthrough eventually occurred "The Wall of Death").

Other things are more distracting. Added to a number of typos, scattered errors, and some repeated passages are more potentially troubling areas. For example, a limited sampling of the book's references revealed a striking number of sloppy mistakes. While their substance does not raise serious alarm bells along the lines of mishandling of sources, one can only hope that similar lack of attention to detail did not extend to more important areas of the author's research and writing. More explicitly objectionable is the author's tone in places. Even though the book engages an admittedly weak historiography, the author's collective disparagement of the existing literature is a bit over the top, and his derisive comment about prior Gaines' Mill authors all being "eggheads" has no useful place in a serious historical study. Thankfully, once the reader gets beyond the preface a different and much-improved authorial attitude and tone are evidenced.

The book's cartography is a major strength, and the author is to be commended for making it a priority. Operational and tactical maps are plentiful in number and generous in both unit and terrain detail, though space and/or source limitations often forced a mixing of military scaling between regiments and brigades/"battle groups." Multi-sourced orders of battle are present in the appendix section, and they refreshingly include regimental strength and loss data (though the notes rather surprisingly do not reference Leon Tenney's pioneering research). The OB material is enhanced on the Union side with battery compositions along with weapons information for select infantry units.

The definitive study of this battle is yet to be published, but A Bloody Day at Gaines' Mill represents a step forward in more than enough ways to make it worthy of at least qualified recommendation. Among all existing Gaines's Mill treatments, this one is without peer when it comes to providing readers with a comprehensive interpretation of the entire course and flow of the battle at the small-unit level. It will be very interesting to compare Woodard's version of events to R.E.L. Krick's much anticipated study, if or when that one ever gets completed and published.

Tuesday, April 30, 2019

Booknotes: Held in Highest Esteem by All

New Arrival:
• Held in Highest Esteem by All: The Civil War Letters of William B. Chilvers, 95th Illinois Infantry edited by Thomas A. Pressly, III and Gary D. Joiner (State House Pr, 2018).

From the description: "As an orphan, William Burnham Chilvers did not have parents to coach him through his journey of life that took him across the sea from Great Britain to the United States. Shortly after immigrating, he found a home in the army and campaigned with the 95th Illinois Infantry. Years of hard marching and tough fighting carried him through the Vicksburg Campaign and into Louisiana and the Red River Campaign. He served in Missouri, then at Nashville and Brice’s Crossroads, before finishing his career assaulting the Confederate works near Mobile, Alabama. Through it all, Chilvers was a strong abolitionist and sympathetic to the plight of slaves. He wrote about the atrocities faced by African Americans at the hands of Southern whites—as well as by his fellow Union soldiers."

Editors Pressly and Joiner fill Held in Highest Esteem by All: The Civil War Letters of William B. Chilvers, 95th Illinois Infantry with maps, photographs, and abundant supporting narrative. They also extensively annotate the Chilvers material. In the appendix section are unit and personal chronologies, a regimental index, and a list of other 95th Ill. diarists and letter writers.

Chilvers's "letters and the editors’ research tell stories of massacres, combat, and idealism in the face of the brutal realities of war. Will Chilvers and the 95th Illinois Infantry fought to victory, but his experience transcends mere combat and instead reveals the development of a remarkable man whose compassion and humanity rose above the ugliness of the Civil War."

Monday, April 29, 2019

Five Books on the Capture and Occupation of New Orleans

On this week 157 years ago, New Orleans fell to Union forces in shocking fashion. Many observers then and now (including the author of an upcoming ECW volume) have deemed the sudden loss of the South's largest city and its extensive port and manufacturing facilities a "mortal blow" to Confederate hopes. I've often lamented the many missed publishing opportunities of the Sesquicentennial and one of the biggest was the absence of a new study of Civil War New Orleans (which actually merits a multi-volume treatment integrating military history with occupation, emancipation, and wartime reconstruction studies). Admittedly, that would be quite a project. In the meantime, here are five books worth checking out.

1. The Night the War Was Lost by Charles L. Dufour (1960).
The late Art Bergeron was my go to guy when it came to advice about the best Civil War Louisiana books and articles. With the obvious caveat that the field of contenders was, and is still, decidedly light (there are really only two), it was Art's opinion that Dufour's older study was the best available. I agree, though without any great enthusiasm. In all my visits to libraries and bookstores, I don't believe I ever saw a copy of the original hardcover edition. My own reading experience was with the 1994 Bison Books reissue that had the cool cover art.
2. The Capture of New Orleans, 1862 by Chester G. Hearn (1995).
Hearn's book provides readers with a serviceable account of the military campaign that resulted in the Crescent City's fall.
3. A Civil War Correspondent in New Orleans: The Journals and Reports of Albert Gaius Hills of the Boston Journal edited by Gary L. Dyson (2012).
This is my favorite collection of eyewitness accounts of the campaign written by a civilian observer.
4. Mutiny at Fort Jackson: The Untold Story of the Fall of New Orleans by Michael D. Pierson (2012).
I didn't buy in to every element of Pierson's thesis, but he definitely presents an interesting non-traditional take on the role Fort Jackson's disaffected rank-and-file defenders (whom the author alleges to have been closet-Unionists) had in hastening the city's fall.
5. Occupied City: New Orleans under the Federals 1862-1865 by Gerald J. Capers (1965).
It says something about the dated state of the literature that the standard work on the long-term occupation of a city as significant as New Orleans was to both sides is over five decades old. We are certainly due for a new one. More recent work has greatly revised the image and legacy of Benjamin Butler, who was the "Beast" of New Orleans to many but also bettered the lot of the city's poorer classes and made it a much healthier and safer place to live as well.

Sunday, April 28, 2019

Coming Soon (May '19 Edition)

NEW RELEASES scheduled for May 2019:
• Rediscovering Fort Sanders: The American Civil War and Its Impact on Knoxville's Cultural Landscape by Teresa and Charles Faulkner.
• Industrial Development and Manufacturing in the Antebellum Gulf South: A Reevaluation by Michael Frawley.
• Alabamians in Blue: Freedmen, Unionists, and the Civil War in the Cotton State by Christopher Rein.
• Conquered: Why the Army of Tennessee Failed by Larry Daniel.
• Owen Lovejoy and the Coalition for Equality: Clergy, African Americans, and Women United for Abolition by Jane Ann and William Moore.
• Opdycke's Tigers in the Civil War: A History of the 125th Ohio Volunteer Infantry by Thomas Crowl.
• War, Memory, and the 1913 Gettysburg Reunion by Thomas Flagel.
• Don Troiani's Gettysburg: 36 Masterful Paintings and Riveting History of the Civil War's Epic Battle by Don Troiani and Tom Huntington.
• Civil War Medicine: A Surgeon's Diary ed. by Robert Hicks.

May looks like a little bit of a slow down from last month, which I still haven't come close to catching up with yet for Booknotes entries. The reading backlog is even worse. Damn flu. The Fort Sanders book has had a 5/7 release date settled for quite a while now, so I hope to see it released this month [ed.: it just changed to December 2019]. Larry Daniel's breakdown of the many reasons behind the Confederate Army of Tennessee's lack of success in the West is one of my most highly anticipated titles of this catalog season.

Friday, April 26, 2019

Booknotes: Rosebud, June 17, 1876

New Arrival:
• Rosebud, June 17, 1876: Prelude to the Little Big Horn by Paul L. Hedren (OU Press, 2019).

With a large host of scholarly publications already to his credit, it's probably an understatement to say that Paul Hedren is one of our leading experts on the Sioux Wars fought during the latter half of the nineteenth century. In terms of getting a dream matchup with an author and a subject in need of a definitive-scale treatment, it doesn't get much better than Hedren and the Rosebud battle.

Some topical background from the description: "The Battle of the Rosebud may well be the largest Indian battle ever fought in the American West. The monumental clash on June 17, 1876, along Rosebud Creek in southeastern Montana pitted George Crook and his Shoshone and Crow allies against Sioux and Northern Cheyennes under Sitting Bull and Crazy Horse. It set the stage for the battle that occurred eight days later when, just twenty-five miles away, George Armstrong Custer blundered into the very same village that had outmatched Crook. Historian Paul L. Hedren presents the definitive account of this critical battle, from its antecedents in the Sioux campaign to its historic consequences."

I'm not sure what is currently considered the standard history of the battle. My admittedly light search didn't reveal many full-length contenders. I would imagine that Neal Mangum's similarly titled Battle of the Rosebud: Prelude to the Little Big Horn is highly regarded, but it appears to be less than half the length of this one. 

More from the description: Hedren's Rosebud, June 17, 1876: Prelude to the Little Big Horn "explores in unprecedented detail the events of the spring and early summer of 1876. Drawing on an extensive array of sources, including government reports, diaries, reminiscences, and a previously untapped trove of newspaper stories, the book traces the movements of both Indian forces and U.S. troops and their Indian allies as Brigadier General Crook commenced his second great campaign against the northern Indians for the year. Both Indian and army paths led to Rosebud Creek, where warriors surprised Crook and then parried with his soldiers for the better part of a day on an enormous field. Describing the battle from multiple viewpoints, Hedren narrates the action moment by moment, capturing the ebb and flow of the fighting. Throughout he weighs the decisions and events that contributed to Crook’s tactical victory, and to his fateful decision thereafter not to pursue his adversary. The result is a uniquely comprehensive view of an engagement that made history and then changed its course."

Six maps accompany the text, with three covering the June 17 fighting at the tactical scale. Orders of battle and casualty assessments can be found in the appendix section.

Thursday, April 25, 2019

Review - "Presidents, Battles, and Must-See Civil War Destinations: Exploring a Kentucky Divided" by Ludwick & Hess

[Presidents, Battles, and Must-See Civil War Destinations: Exploring a Kentucky Divided by Cameron M. Ludwick and Blair Thomas Hess (Indiana University Press, 2019). Softcover, photographs, links, select bibliography. Pages main/total:xi,63/104. ISBN:978-0-253-03896-8. $16]

The authors of three road trip guides exploring their state's history, its famous bourbons, and delicious foodways, Cameron Ludwick and Blair Thomas Hess's fourth collaboration is Presidents, Battles, and Must-See Civil War Destinations: Exploring a Kentucky Divided. Not a step-by-step touring manual on the level of those containing extensive historical orientation, elaborate sets of directions, or comprehensive collections of interpretive stops, their book is more of an introductory-level idea guide.

Arranged into three chapters—"Presidents," "Battles," and "Kentucky War Stories"— the book invites readers to consider a range of persons and places related to the Bluegrass State's involvement in the American Civil War. The first chapter visits the birthplace sites and local influences of two opposing presidents, Abraham Lincoln and Jefferson Davis. The battle section looks at sites of Civil War armed conflict in the state and includes in its coverage Columbus, Sacramento, Munfordville, Camp Wildcat, Mill Springs, Ivy Mountain, Middle Creek, Perryville, and places associated with John Hunt Morgan's raids. Background information is generally limited to just a few paragraphs, but the wide geographical spread is nice to encounter as well as the text's mix of large and small battles, both famous and obscure. The final chapter adds more context for the secession period and some information about the state's wartime governors (including the exiled Confederate ones). Some state landmarks, such as Fort Boonsboro, are briefly discussed as are the lives of a handful of prominent individuals (ex. William Wells Brown and Cassius Clay) whose stories provide new readers with human-interest entryways into the state's complex relationship with slavery.

In each section, the authors offer useful tips in their "If You Go" sidebars for visitors. These offer advice in the areas of general trip logistics, behavioral expectations when attending certain events, how to take advantage of existing tour resources, and more. The main text is only 63 pages, plus a large collection of unpaginated color photo galleries, so the entire volume can be easily read in a single sitting. Additional tour-specific details for most of the locations covered can be found by visiting the websites listed at the back of the book.

As a border slave state that remained in the Union but also embraced its Confederate heritage during the postwar period, Kentucky has a Civil War history more complicated than most. In-depth examination of existing controversies over memorials and other aspects of the state's relationship with the Confederate part of its past is clearly beyond the scope of the book, but the issues are mentioned.

In terms of complaints, there are a few historical errors scattered about and the authors do in their "Battle of Columbus" section slyly appropriate for Kentucky the Missouri battle of Belmont (though, to be fair, the fortress on the bluffs did play a lesser role in the battle). The volume might also have benefited by inclusion of a state driving map showing the location of all the places mentioned in the text.

Expert history travelers already have extensive tools available at their finger tips, but reading Presidents, Battles, and Must-See Civil War Destinations should be a useful initial step for those planning their first family trip through Kentucky's Civil War backroads.

Wednesday, April 24, 2019

Booknotes: The War Criminal's Son

New Arrival:
• The War Criminal's Son: The Civil War Saga of William A. Winder by Jane Singer (Potomac Books, 2019).

General John H. Winder remains the object of controversy stemming from his various bureaucratic leadership roles in the Confederate prison system, but I'll confess to being a bit taken aback by the title of Jane Singer's The War Criminal's Son: The Civil War Saga of William A. Winder. There's certainly no consensus among historians of Civil War prisons that the general is deserving of such a label typically reserved for humanity's worst of the worst. 

Anyway, the book is really the story of his eldest son, William Andrew Winder, who remained loyal to the Union. When the war began Winder was a U.S. Army lieutenant stationed at Alcatraz Island. Soon promoted to captain of the Third Artillery's Company M, he eagerly sought more active service.

From the description: "Despite his pleas to remain at the front, it was not enough. Winder was ordered to command Alcatraz, a fortress that became a Civil War prison, where he treated his prisoners humanely despite repeated accusations of disloyalty and treason because the Winder name had become shorthand for brutality during an already brutal war.

John Winder died before he could be brought to justice as a war criminal. Haunted by his father’s villainy, William went into a self-imposed exile for twenty years and eventually ended up at the Rosebud Reservation in South Dakota, to fulfill his longstanding desire to better the lot of Native Americans.
"

In The War Criminal’s Son "Jane Singer evokes the universal themes of loyalty, shame, and redemption in the face of unspeakable cruelty."

Tuesday, April 23, 2019

Booknotes: The Most Desperate Acts of Gallantry

New Arrival:
• The Most Desperate Acts of Gallantry: George A. Custer in the Civil War by Daniel T. Davis (Savas Beatie, 2019).

George Armstrong Custer will always be most popularly remembered for getting himself and five entire companies of his regiment killed at the Little Big Horn during his rash assault on the Indian villages there in Montana, but I always think of him foremost as a successful Civil War cavalry general. Daniel Davis's The Most Desperate Acts of Gallantry: George A. Custer in the Civil War offers readers a brief but thorough summary of that meteoric career, which saw him rise from fresh West Point graduate to brevet major general.

From the description: "Plucked from obscurity by Maj. Gen. George McClellan, Custer served as a staff officer through the early stages of the war. His star began to rise in late June, 1863, when he catapulted several grades to brigadier general and was given brigade command. Shortly thereafter, at Gettysburg and Buckland Mills, he led his men—the Wolverines—in some of the heaviest cavalry fighting of the Eastern Theater.

At Yellow Tavern, Custer’s assault broke the enemy line, and one of his troopers mortally wounded the legendary Confederate cavalryman, J.E.B. Stuart. At Trevilian Station, his brigade was nearly destroyed. At Third Winchester, he participated in an epic cavalry charge. Elevated to lead the Third Cavalry Division, Custer played a major role at Tom’s Brook and, later, at Appomattox, which ultimately led to the surrender of the Army of Northern Virginia.
"

Supporting this comprehensive introductory narrative is a host of new and archival photographs along with an excellent set of maps from ECW series cartographer Hall Jesperson. Modern images of seemingly every landscape vista across which Custer and his men charged enemy lines are included in the book. The final chapter briefly examines the war hero's post-Civil War life, and in the first-person epilogue the author walks in Custer's doomed footsteps at the Little Big Horn.

The appendix section contains four entries. Author Daniel Davis discusses the life of decorated Custer brother Tom and also contributes the volume's final word on the Custer legacy. In the other two, Ashley Webb looks at the relationship between George and Libby Custer, and Paul Ashdown assesses the Custer memory.

Monday, April 22, 2019

Review - "Farragut's Captain: Percival Drayton, 1861-1865" by Peter Barratt

[Farragut's Captain: Percival Drayton, 1861-1865 by Peter Barratt (Author/Lulu, 2018). Softcover, maps, photos, drawings, notes, bibliography. Pages main/total:xv,138/187. ISBN:978-1-4834-8795-3. $16.27]

Civil War naval subcommanders do not receive nearly the levels of notoriety and attention that their army equivalents do in the literature. Union admirals such as David G. Farragut, David Dixon Porter, Andrew H. Foote, and others could not have achieved their enduring fame without the talented professional core of senior captains that carried out their orders and managed for the nation its indispensable naval yards and other key onshore installations. Among the most accomplished of these senior captains was Percival Drayton. The native Charlestonian Drayton was born in 1812 at the beginning of one major American war and died in August 1865 soon after the conclusion of another. A relatively slim volume that concentrates its attention on the Civil War period, Peter Barratt's Farragut's Captain: Percival Drayton, 1861-1865 is the first standalone biography of the officer to be published.

The book begins with a very brief overview of the ideological schism that emerged within the Drayton family during the Jacksonian Era, one that led Percival's staunchly anti-Nullification father to leave South Carolina for Philadelphia. Problems and divisions multiplied during the secession crisis. Drayton's place of birth definitely raised the risk that his personal and professional loyalty would be doubted by the U.S. Navy (these were quickly dispelled though) and the Civil War further divided his already troubled family (Percival's older brother, Thomas, would become a Confederate brigadier general).

In less than 150 pages of narrative, Barratt recounts Drayton's rather illustrious Civil War career, which began at the Philadelphia Naval Yard before moving offshore to serve in the South Atlantic and West Gulf blockading squadrons. Under flag officer (and later admiral) Samuel F. Du Pont, Drayton commanded ships in action at Port Royal and Charleston and engaged in extensive coastal reconnaissance operations and blockade enforcement. Quickly becoming Du Pont's right hand man, Drayton assisted in the capture of Fernandina and Jacksonville in Florida, and he provided naval support for the army's ill-conceived attack at Secessionville. In all of these actions, his ship handling skills and attentiveness to duty impressed his superiors.

Taking a much-needed break from the sea, Drayton then transferred to the Brooklyn Naval Yard to see to the arming and outfitting of the navy's new ocean-going ironclad fleet. Assigned to command the Passaic, Drayton returned to Charleston and participated in Du Pont's failed 1863 naval assault on Charleston harbor. This ship-versus-shore action provided further proof, which Drayton already suspected from his earlier test bombardments of Fort McAllister, that Monitor-class vessels and their descendents alone did not have the firepower in their two-gun turrets to simply blast their way into heavily defended southern ports and harbors. Regardless, Drayton's reputation did not suffer from the failure.

Again taking a hiatus from sea service, Drayton was appointed ordnance superintendent at the Brooklyn Naval Yard. There he renewed his friendship with Admiral Farragut, who arranged for Drayton to join his Gulf command as fleet captain for planned operations against Mobile. Aboard the Hartford, Drayton played an important role as the admiral's chief subordinate during the successful attack on Mobile Bay. Returning north that December. Drayton then spent the balance of the war performing various shore assignments, including court duties he found distasteful. He died suddenly in August 1865 after developing a bowel obstruction.

Basing his biographical narrative heavily on Drayton's own letters and papers, along with those of a core of friends and admirers in the service, Peter Barratt's study is largely celebratory in nature. Even so, the book makes a strong case that Drayton deserves a spot in the top tier of the Union Navy's second-ranking line of officers. Repaying the trust and professional respect of admirals Du Pont and Farragut on multiple occasions, Drayton was consistently appointed to posts of high responsibility during many of the war's most consequential naval campaigns. However, Barratt does occasionally point out some potential flaws. For example, throughout his Civil War career Drayton seemed very committed to interservice rivalry and rarely had anything good to say about his association with the army or its leaders. This suggests that he might have proved to be a very poor candidate for leading any important naval expedition that required close cooperation with the army.

A quick read, Farragut's Captain is a fine account of the Civil War service of a career naval officer highly deserving of greater historical recognition. Recommended.

Saturday, April 20, 2019

Book News: Bull Run to Boer War

Several decades ago when I first started getting into Civil War reading, most general history books and many other types parroted the simplistic view that the major European armies dismissed the armies of both sides as "armed mobs" and saw few lessons to be learned from any serious study of the conflict. I was always skeptical of that but the topic didn't grab me enough to investigate deeper. At one time I had a copy of Jay Luvaas's classic The Military Legacy of the Civil War: The European Inheritance but don't recall if I read it.

During the present mini-explosion of 1864-65 Richmond-Petersburg Campaign publications, discussion of the links between Civil War trench warfare and what occurred on the Western Front during the Great War, though the connection has been downplayed, has resurfaced. Recently I noticed a new study in the pipeline that addresses this topic and many others, Michael Somerville's Bull Run to Boer War: How the American Civil War Changed the British Army (Helion, January 2020). The description has me hooked.
"The American Civil War is often said to have predicted the way in which later wars such as the Boer War and the First World War would be fought. As a result the British Army has been criticised for not heeding its lessons, a view that can be traced back to the 1930s. This book challenges that long-held view, and demonstrates that the responses to the lessons of the war in the British Army were more complex, better informed, and of higher quality, than normally depicted.

Key to this new interpretation is that it takes a nineteenth century perspective rather than pre-supposing what the British should have seen based upon hindsight from the South African veldt or the Western Front trenches. It demonstrates that strategists and policy-makers reacted to the changes in the nature of warfare suggested by American experience, looks at how officers in the cavalry, infantry, artillery and engineers applied their observations in America to the technical and tactical issues of the day, and even examines the war’s influence on the development of aeronautics.

In studying how the Civil War changed the Late Victorian British Army, the book provides insight into its learning process, and concludes that although sometimes flawed, its study of the American Civil War meant that it was better prepared for the wars of the twentieth century than previously acknowledged."

Friday, April 19, 2019

Booknotes: Attack at Daylight and Whip Them

New Arrival:
• Attack at Daylight and Whip Them: The Battle of Shiloh, April 6-7, 1862
  by Gregory A. Mertz (Savas Beatie, 2019).

Having just left Chattanooga, the Emerging Civil War series stays out west with Gregory Mertz's Attack at Daylight and Whip Them: The Battle of Shiloh, April 6-7, 1862. It is one of those volumes that integrates tour and narrative together, as opposed to placing the driving tour at the back like most of the others (I seem to recall) have done. At least in terms of organization, it looks like the text primarily serves the tour here rather than the other way around. This means the battle narrative does not follow a strict chronology, with the content of the later chapters freely moving back and forth between Day 1 and Day 2 events. The concluding chapter examines the immediate aftermath of the battle.

Mertz's book possesses the series's typical abundance of photographs and other illustrations. There are seventeen maps, which is an unusually large number for an ECW entry. The tactical maps depict the action at mostly brigade scale. The single appendix discusses Lew Wallace's ever controversial march to the battlefield on April 6. Army orders of battle and a brief suggested reading list round out the volume.

Thursday, April 18, 2019

Booknotes: Campaign for Wilson's Creek, Updated Edition

New Arrival:
• Campaign for Wilson's Creek: The Fight for Missouri Begins, Updated Edition
  by Jeffrey L. Patrick (State House Pr, 2018).

Originally published in 2011 as part of McWhiney Foundation Press's Civil War Campaigns and Commanders series, Jeff Patrick's Campaign for Wilson's Creek: The Fight for Missouri Begins presents audiences of all backgrounds an excellent overview history of the topic. I would still recommend as the best entry point for new readers. For some time now, McWhiney History Education Group has been publishing new titles, including this one, through their State House Press imprint.

In Campaign for Wilson's Creek: The Fight for Missouri Begins, Updated Edition Patrick "tells the fascinating story of high-stakes military gambles, aggressive leadership, and lost opportunities. Campaign for Wilson's Creek is a tale of unique military units, untried but determined commanders, colorful volunteers, and professional soldiers. The first major campaign of the Civil War to take place west of the Mississippi River guaranteed that Missourians would be engaged in a long, cruel civil war within the larger, national struggle."

At first glance, both editions (2011 and 2018) appear identical beyond the new cover art and copyright page (the latter has a 2018 date, though the book was released in 2019 within the last month). I emailed the publisher and asked if they could offer any information about changes between editions. The response from them indicated that "updated edition" primarily refers to the new book conforming to an updated style guide, with content additions/alterations much less significant.