Booknotes: Opening Manassas

New Arrival:

• Opening Manassas: The Iron Brigade, Stonewall Jackson, and the Battle on Brawner’s Farm, August 28, 1862 by Lance J. Herdegen and Bill Backus (Savas Beatie, 2025).

From the description: In August of 1862, Confederate offensive movements that resulted in Union defeat at Cedar Mountain and the destruction of the massive Union supply base at Manassas Junction finally prompted a strong response from John Pope's Army of Virginia. "Pope withdrew from his defensive line along the Rappahannock determined to find and eradicate the Confederates. First he had to find them. Unbeknownst to Pope, Jackson had deployed his men in a strong wooded defensive position along an abandoned railroad cut. All Old Jack needed was a reason to sally forth and strike an unsuspecting piece of Pope’s scattered army. That opportunity presented itself on the afternoon of August 28 when the Western men, soon to be known as the Iron Brigade, marched along the Warrenton Pike, unaware that danger lurked just yards away off their exposed left flank."

The resulting clash at Brawner's Farm, a very bloody affair considering the numbers involved, was a brutal slugging match. While the tactical performance of the Confederates was pretty uninspiring, the clash cemented the reputation of their Iron Brigade opponents. Brawner's Farm also contributed profoundly to Pope's serial misperception of the military situation on his front. The newest in-depth investigation of this fight, Lance Herdegen and Bill Backus's Opening Manassas: The Iron Brigade, Stonewall Jackson, and the Battle on Brawner’s Farm, August 28, 1862, is "the first full-length balanced study of the affair ever published."

Of course, a great many Civil War studies are the result of research and writing collaboration between more than one author, but this study adopts a highly unconventional framework of co-authoring. More from the description: Opening Manassas "uses a fog-of-war approach to unfold the battle as the soldiers of both sides would have experienced it, and how the various officers reacted with only the information they had at the time. Award-winning author Lance J. Herdegen handles the Union side of the equation, while preservation historian and veteran of the National Park Service, Bill Backus, chronicles the Confederate perspective. Together, chapter by chapter, they march their respective forces to the point of destiny and discover unexpected insights into the engagement and the leadership decisions of both sides." Sounds interesting.