Monday, July 25, 2011

Booknotes V ( July '11 )

New Arrivals:

1. Acadian General Alfred Mouton and the Civil War by William Arceneaux (Center for La Studies, 1981).

According to the publisher, "this revised and expanded edition also incorporates the most recent findings in Acadian and Civil War history, as well as new materials from the National Archives and various Louisiana depositories. Also included in the second edition are the muster rolls for Mouton's Eighteenth Louisiana Regiment and the Acadian general's West Point transcripts". I'll post a snapshot review when I finish it.

2. A Man And His Boat: The Civil War Career And Correspondence of Lieut. Jonathan Carter, CSN by Katherine Brash Jeter (Center for La Studies, 1996).

This is a nice collection of naval primary source material for the Trans-Mississippi. Carter was involved with the construction of the CSS Missouri, a problem plagued ironclad launched at Shreveport in 1863.

Thursday, July 21, 2011

Booknotes IV ( July '11 )

New Arrivals:

1. The Great Heart of the Republic: St. Louis and the Cultural Civil War by Adam Arenson (Harvard Univ Pr, 2011).

I liked Louis Gerteis's Civil War St. Louis, and, while both books appear superficially similar in their focus on society and politics, Arenson's new study takes a broader and more long term view at the importance of St. Louis to 19th century cultural change in America.

2. An Iowa Soldier Writes Home: The Civil War Letters of Union Private Daniel J. Parvin edited by Phillip A. Hubbart (Carolina Academic Pr, 2011).

This book is an edited collection of 117 letters from a private in the 11th Iowa. Parvin fought first in Missouri in 1861-62 before heading to the western theater and the battlefields of Shiloh, Vicksburg, and Atlanta. Editor Phillip Hubbart bucks tradition, organizing the material thematically rather than chronologically. I am curious to see how well the method works in practice.

Tuesday, July 19, 2011

Snapshots from the Collection: "From Desert to Bayou"

According to Civil War in the desert Southwest expert Jerry D. Thompson, of the half dozen or so published diaries and journals from the 1861-62 Confederate invasion of New Mexico and Arizona, only Morgan Merrick's covers the summer 1861 occupation of the Mesilla Valley by John R. Baylor's 2nd Texas Mounted Rifles. His 77-page journal [originally titled "Notes And Sketches of Campaigns In New Mexico, Arizona, Texas, Louisiana, and Arkansas By A Participant Dr. M. W. Merrick From Fb. 16th 1861 To May 26th 1865 Actual Service, In the Field"] was published in 1991 by Texas Western Press under the title From Desert to Bayou: The Civil War Journal and Sketches of Morgan Wolfe Merrick.

Thompson contributed an introduction and detailed notes, but perhaps From Desert to Bayou 's greatest value lies in its dozens of color reproductions of Merrick's sketches and paintings. In addition to many detailed drawings of the regional architecture, Merrick sketched maps, landscapes, camps, forts, and battle scenes. A series of portraits of Mescalero Apaches encountered by Merrick are among the more unusual images. The native New Yorker but pre-war San Antonio resident also fought in Louisiana with the 3rd Texas Cavalry (Co. E). There he continued his amateur artwork, completing several camp and battle scenes from the shores of the Mississippi and in the LaFourche District. From Desert to Bayou is a very worthwhile personal and visual record of the Civil War in the Trans-Mississippi.

Sunday, July 17, 2011

Ride Around Missouri

At this time, the only history of Jo Shelby's 1863 "Great Raid" published in book form is Mark Scott's  The Fifth Season (Two Trails Pub., 2001). However, Sean McLachlan's Ride Around Missouri - Shelby's Great Raid 1863 is expected to have an October release. A short work [the standard 80 pages] from Osprey's Raid series, not much more than an overview treatment can be expected.

Saturday, July 16, 2011

Booknotes III ( July '11 )

New Arrivals:

1. Savannah, Immortal City: Volume I - Civil War Savannah by Barry Sheehy & Cindy Wallace with Vaughnette Goode-Walker (Emerald Book Co., 2011).

A heavy oversize volume (first of a four volume set) bound in red cloth and full of maps, photos, and other illustrations, this glossy text and visual history of Savannah during the war is full of architecture lore interspersed with annotated historical narrative.

2. Violent Encounters: Interviews on Western Massacres by Deborah and John Lawrence (U of Okla Pr, 2011).

Prominent western massacres are examined in a Q&A format with recognized experts. The two most Civil War-related cover Sand Creek and the Santee Sioux uprising. I like it a great deal so far.

Monday, July 11, 2011

Snapshots from the Collection: "Sibley's New Mexico Campaign"

I'll always have a soft spot for Martin Hardwick Hall's Sibley's New Mexico Campaign (University of Texas Press, 1960). It was the first serious study I read (albeit over three decades after its release) about a campaign fought west of the Mississippi and I've been hooked ever since. Though relatively brief by today's standards, it's coverage of the desert campaign from inception through the Confederate retreat back to Texas holds up better than most 1960s campaign studies. A particularly noteworthy inclusion was a complete roster of the Confederate force.  Hall, a doctoral student under T. Harry Williams, also completed a companion reference work The Confederate Army of New Mexico (Presidial Press, 1978).  Tragically, he was murdered in his home in 1981, the perpetrator never found.

In 2000, Sibley's New Mexico Campaign was reissued by the University of New Mexico Press (with a foreword by Jerry D. Thompson). The new edition contains a number of minor corrections discovered by Hall after the original publication (and noted by Hall in Thompson's personal copy). The five maps that accompanied the first edition are absent, replaced by a single theater image.  While the more recent campaign overview authored by Donald Frazier is excellent and several of the battles have received their own book length studies from capable talents like Don Alberts, it remains a worthwhile endeavor to go back and review the work of the man that started it all, Martin Hardwick Hall.

Friday, July 8, 2011

Hatfield: "THE OTHER FEUD: William Anderson "Devil Anse" Hatfield in the Civil War"

[The Other Feud: William Anderson "Devil Anse" Hatfield in the Civil War by Philip Hatfield (Author-Createspace, 2010). Softcover, illustrations, tables, notes. Pages main/total:80/99. ISBN:9781453886748  $12.99]

Much has been published about the Hatfield-McCoy feud from the popular and academic presses, but Philip Hatfield's The Other Feud explores instead the Civil War years of William Anderson "Devil Anse" Hatfield's life. Just how much of this Civil War service information is freshly presented in the book, I'll have to leave to those familiar with the extensive Hatfield-McCoy literature. Earlier biographical works, such as The Tale of the Devil, do claim to cover the period.  A slim volume of small physical dimensions and large print, The Other Feud has the modest goal of summarizing Hatfield's Civil War career as well as discussing to what degree Civil War differences fed the famous feud, a subject of some controversy.

Utilizing service records and the excellent research of SE Kentucky-SW Virginia Civil War researchers Jeffrey Weaver and Randall Osborne, the author traces William A. Hatfield's association with the Virginia militia, Virginia State Line, and 45th Virginia Infantry Battalion. Making use of the O.R., books, newspapers, and manuscript material, the narrative often strays away from sustained mention of Hatfield personal involvement in events (his presence in assumed), instead summarizing the military movements and actions of the state and Confederate units. The work is most speculative in its dealing of the 1864-65 period following Devil Anse Hatfield's desertion from the 45th Virginia Battalion. His name is absent from the rolls of Bill Smith's guerrilla unit and, according to the author, no supporting documentation has been discovered. Nevertheless, author Hatfield wholeheartedly adopts the traditional view that "Devil Anse" fought with Smith. Even with the recognition that muster roll information for partisan units was necessarily spotty at best and it was often in an irregular fighter's best interest not to have his name in print, the author might have been better served to leave the details of this aspect of the Devil's life more open to debate.

As for the question of the alleged Civil War origins of the feud, the text is largely inconclusive as to the depth of the role played by the great national conflict*. It does, however, persuasively argue against the popular notion that the feud had a North (McCoy) vs. South (Hatfield) character. In support of this, author Hatfield provides a pair of nice tables which list the wartime services of prominent members of the post-war feud. These appendices demonstrate no clear sectional divide. While no feuding Hatfield directly served in Union forces, relatives did, and McCoy feudists fought on both sides.

Happily, the author also writes dispassionately, refreshingly avoiding the pitfalls of biographical history penned by direct or collateral descendents. On the down side, the book needs some editing work and would have benefited from a bibliography and index. A concluding chapter summarizing the author's findings would also have been helpful. In the end, The Other Feud's often presumptive assessment of William A. Hatfield's personal involvement in the war tends to raise as many questions as it attempts to answer. While in broad terms the book achieves what it sets out to do, given its limitations of length and scope, readers might best view it as a starting point for further exploration.

* - The book does not cite James Prichard's excellent recent article from Virginia at War, 1863 (UP of Kentucky, 2009). Prichard takes the view that the character of the post-war Hatfield-McCoy feud was a direct consequence of Civil War mountain guerrilla warfare and offers details pertaining to Hatfield's involvement in that aspect of the war. While Philip Hatfield's work doesn't aspire to the scholarly reaches of Prichard's creation of a broader sociological context, it would have been worthwhile to address the article's conclusions.

Wednesday, July 6, 2011

Booknotes II ( July '11 )

New Arrivals:

1. Touring the Carolina's Civil War Sites 2nd Ed. by Clint Johnson (John F. Blair, 2011)

2. Touring Virginia's and West Virginia's Civil War Sites 2nd Ed. by Clint Johnson (John F. Blair, 2011).

These are state wide touring books broken down into day trip sized chunks.  I've never seen the first editions of these works so an assessment of improvements made can't be made by me.

3. Battlefield Angels: Saving Lives Under Enemy Fire From Valley Forge to Afghanistan by Scott McGaugh (Osprey Publishing, 2011).

This book examines the history of U.S. military medicine through theme based chapters centering on specific conflicts. The Civil War chapter looks at battlefield evacuation.

Monday, July 4, 2011

Badgers in the Swamps

Regular readers know I will rarely resist a new book about the Civil War in Missouri (at least the non-bushwhacker stuff). Recently, I learned from the trusty History-Sites messageboard for Missouri about Paul Arnold's plan to publish his thesis Badgers in the Swamps: The 1st Wisconsin Cavalry in Southeast Missouri, 1862-1863 later on this year. Beyond a few journal articles, there's not much in the way of good material published about the war in this region during this time period.  I'm looking forward to it.

Sunday, July 3, 2011

Entrusting your battle plan to Beauregard is like a box of choc-o-lates

Novelist-history writer Winston Groom is taking on another great western battle with Shiloh, 1862: The First Great and Terrible Battle of the Civil War (National Geographic, Mar 2012). If the early details are correct, it's a big one at over 500 pages. I haven't read any of his Civil War books, and a quick thumb through his Vicksburg book didn't induce me to try, so I'll probably wait for Cozzens. Presumably, Peter will try to get his out for the 150th as well, but I have no idea.

Saturday, July 2, 2011

"Railroads of the Civil War: An Illustrated History"

The logistical, strategic, operational, and tactical (in the form of armored trains and rail guns) military uses of railroads are not exactly neglected subjects by Civil War publishers. While it is true that the narrative covering these important facets of rail history in Michael Leavy's Railroads of the Civil War: An Illustrated History (Westholme, 2010) is familiar and largely of generalist appeal, where Leavy's work truly shines is in his deft selection of accompanying images, many of which have never been published before.

The photographic reproductions in the book are clear and large in size. Photos and text are organized into chapters by theme. Historical background of rail development in the country is provided, as well as general surveys of the northern and southern rail nets. Specific lines of critical importance, such as the Baltimore & Ohio, are singled out for more detailed treatment. Materially, everything is covered from equipment (e.g. engines, tenders, rolling stock) to the bridges, stations, and roundhouses essential to their operation. The destruction visited upon the tracks, equipment, and supporting structures is another prominent theme and image source. The reader is finally left with the Lincoln funeral train. Railroads of the Civil War should have points of interest for many readers, regardless of knowledge base.

Booknotes ( July '11 )

New Arrivals:

* Enacting History edited by Scott Magelssen and Rhona Justice-Malloy (U of Ala Pr, 2011).

The editors of this essay collection argue, with the typical misgivings, for the importance of "historical performances" (i.e. "living history museums, battle reenactments, pageants, renaissance festivals, and adventure-tourism destinations") in bringing history to the masses.

Wednesday, June 29, 2011

Booknotes III ( June '11 )

New Arrivals:

* A pair of self-published books by Philip Hatfield, The Other Feud: William Anderson "Devil Anse" Hatfield in the Civil War (2010) and How the North Carolina Militia Helped Start the Civil War (2011).

"Devil Anse" Hatfield's involvement in the Civil War fighting along the Virginia-Kentucky border is the subject of the first book. Some readers may recall the chronicling of these events in a nice article from the 1863 volume of the Virginia At War series published by Univ Pr of Kentucky. The second work, also brief, discusses the pre-secession seizure of coastal forts Johnston and Caswell by local NC citizen groups. Federal control of these installations was restored with an apology from the governor, but they were retaken at the war's outset.

Monday, June 27, 2011

Civil War in NE Arkansas

I have a fairly generous tolerance for flawed local history if the subject is fresh and Freeman Mobley's Making Sense of the Civil War in Batesville-Jacksonport and Northeast Arkansas 1861-1874 (Author, 2005) isn't a great book by any means. It is a clear upgrade over an earlier work that covers some of the same ground, Lady Elizabeth Watson's Fight and Survive!: The Civil War in Jackson County, Arkansas (River Road Pr, 1974). Given that, I think the reissuing of Mobley's book (under the new title Civil War!: A Missing Piece of the Puzzle Northeast Arkansas 1861-1874) is worthy of mention as it covers reasonably well a geographical region largely neglected in the Arkansas Civil War literature.